I'm a well read grad student who's bluntly honest about all things, although I try to be most honest about myself.
Wonderful storyline, full of action and mystery and politics, all surrounding an experiment with clones. It's also an insanely fast read, partly because I needed to know what happens to Luke's family, so I just keep reading, frantic to know if they'd be saved.
The one problem I had was with one aspect of the art, and it distracted me enough to knock down one star. The art is fantastic, especially in the sketchbook in the back, but the shading is this weird pointillism style and I did not like it at all.