1475 Autobots
440 Decepticons
allhailgrimlock

Grimlock ♥ Vision

I'm a well read technosexual who's bluntly honest about all things, although I try to be most honest about myself.   

Currently reading

Tongues of Serpents
Naomi Novik
Progress: 122/355pages
A Long December
Richard Chizmar
Progress: 20%
Victory of Eagles (Temeraire)
Naomi Novik
Progress: 384/384pages
Havemercy
Danielle Bennett, Jaida Jones
Progress: 154/431pages
Wayward Deluxe Edition Vol. 1
Tamra Bonvillain, Jim Zub, John Rauch, Steve Cummings
Progress: 184/324pages
After the Apocalypse
Maureen F. McHugh
Progress: 127/201pages
Uprooted
Naomi Novik
Progress: 241/435pages
Glitterbomb #4
Djibril Morissette-Phan, K. Michael Russell, Jim Zub
Flying Higher: an Anthology of Superhero Poetry
Michael Damian Thomas, Shira Lipkin
Progress: 3/76pages
G.E.N.I.E.
Michelle Knight
Progress: 12/258pages

So, so trope-y

The Immortal Iron Fist, Vol. 1: The Last Iron Fist Story - Ed Brubaker, Matt Fraction, David Aja, Travel Foreman

Look, I have other issues - why is fire masculine and water female which seems rather random - but mostly... so much white savior bullshit.   Why has Danny Rand lived in the heavenly city of K'un Lun and yet it's Luke Cage who calls out the Americanized Chinese take out while Rand is like 'yum, spring rolls'?   Seriously, a heavenly city has worse food than American Chinese takeout?   Alright, then.   Totally buy that.  

 

or the fact that the last two Iron Fists are white?   This is a Chinese heavenly city, and the majority of the Iron Fists are Asiatic.   The whole thing about this being a white savior story is that Danny Rand - and apparently other Rand's - came in and co-opted the power.   (I also have a hard time believing that Rand was so easily accepted as basically native born.   But I think this was retroactively trying to make it seem like less of a white savior trope, and it failed miserably on that count if so.)

 

Why can Rand not master the kung fu in the book of Iron Fist secret kung fu when he has the audacity to claim that he has the best kung fu?  (After taking the chi from the previous Iron Fist, who was also white, because apparently two white men make the best kung fu ever.   Again, so much white savior trope here.  Also, he says he has the best kung fu with a straight face after admitting some of the kung fu principles were way too hard for him, so totally not a plot hole or anything...)

 

And it wasn't awful, not by a long shot.   I mean, yes, the whole weird racial stuff was weird as crap and awful; stripped of that, this would make an excellent story.   If I were reading about an Asian, or hell, even Asian American Iron Fist that would help so much.   If this stuck to the story instead of weird-ass gendered elements that would be awesome.   But instead, this was a really good story trapped inside a white savior story. 

 

Sighs.  Somehow the new Power Man and Iron Fist story manages to be just a little less tropey so I can enjoy it a hell of a lot more!